|
|
Post by Lionhardt on Nov 27, 2022 3:19:03 GMT
Have you watched the series friend? It wasn't that great for my taste and their weapon designs aren't that great. Ehh.... I was pretty happy with the show. But I have heard mostly very positive opinions of the swords. Galadriel's sword for one thing, maaaan, amazing. |
|
|
|
Post by Lionhardt on Mar 21, 2023 23:56:09 GMT
It seems this is getting very close. Just read an update from Kit that he is just waiting on some final hilt examples from the maker; one with a clear coat, one without. He wants without but they are pushing the clear coat.... But interestingly enough, they canned the silver coat on it! So it is just going to be polished steel, not silver!
On another note, they are definitely making a Rohan Axe out of high carbon steel and a quality wood!! I contacted Drew about that and he said it would indeed be functional if sharpened up! So that is incredible. That will be the first truly functional UC LOTR weapon! Wow. It doesn't even seem like it will be much of a wait on that one, it is all set, just need to make them!
Good stuff.
|
|
|
|
Post by Eric Bergeron on Mar 25, 2023 1:27:07 GMT
I like the sound of the Rohan axe!
|
|
|
|
Post by warriorpoet on Mar 28, 2023 14:16:04 GMT
Agreed, definitely liking the idea of a usable Rohan axe
|
|
Jash
Member
"Igitur qui desiderat pacem, praeparet bellum!"
Posts: 299
|
Post by Jash on Mar 31, 2023 3:47:21 GMT
roth - never worry about the stainless versus "real" debate. The most important thing is that you enjoy your sword. After all, it's a hobby for your enjoyment! If you plan on using the sword - then you can always get 2 versions: one stainless display and one functional  haha atsehashke - as Lionhardt stated BudK is the place to go if you're in the US. BudK owns United Cutlery so it would be difficult finding these LOTR replicas for a better price somewhere else brand new. In addition - Kult of Athena is a very trustworthy site, but do not carry the full lineup. Castle Kon is another highly trusted vendor. He tries to give his customers the best price and is well known for shipping items internationally. If you're in another county then we'll have to circle back to this question. @lionhardt - wasn't the original Uruk Scimitar made from tool steel and heat treated? With a full tang? I can't remember at the moment lol. But I always thought that was the *first* "functional" piece? Regardless - the Rohan Axe looks sweet! Man... i'm disappointed they scrapped the silver plated fittings. That was part of the "Museum Collection" was it not? So the MC Anduril will NOT have the display case (for obvious reasons), will NOT be limited, and now will NOT have the silver fittings? So the only thing it has in common with the other MC series is a carbon blade, correct?
|
|
|
|
Post by Lionhardt on Mar 31, 2023 19:34:11 GMT
@lionhardt - wasn't the original Uruk Scimitar made from tool steel and heat treated? With a full tang? I can't remember at the moment lol. But I always thought that was the *first* "functional" piece? Regardless - the Rohan Axe looks sweet! Man... i'm disappointed they scrapped the silver plated fittings. That was part of the "Museum Collection" was it not? So the MC Anduril will NOT have the display case (for obvious reasons), will NOT be limited, and now will NOT have the silver fittings? So the only thing it has in common with the other MC series is a carbon blade, correct? Leave it up to Jash, as usual, to swoop in out of nowhere, with useful info! You got me there sir, I am not sure about the Urukai Scimitar! You are probably right! And I hear ya about how this "Museum Collection" piece is changing.... But I believe Glamdring is the only one that had it anyway. I don't believe Sting not Sam's sword had it. So I don't think that is necessarily a staple of the MC line. Now, the limited edition aspect and display box are a bummer I suppose, but not a huge deal. As far as setting it apart goes, and them still calling it a MC sword.... It seems they are still putting a decent amount of effort into making it nicer and more accurate than any of the other versions. Deeper better runes and a better finish on the blade and hilt. Then of course the carbon blade. Does that made it a MC version, or just another version? If UC is suggesting it is the best they can do, combined with the carbon blade, then I suppose that makes it enough of a MC version for me! I don't necessarily need the silver so long as they insist their metal and finish look just as good if not better. Honestly, I think I am glad they aren't doing the silver. It is extremely delicate. Just about any other finish should be more durable. And it seems that is greatly why they steered away from silver, so I am more than ok with that. |
|
|
|
Post by warriorpoet on Apr 4, 2023 21:43:08 GMT
The uruk scimitar was 1055 carbon, but I don't think it was heat treated
|
|
Jash
Member
"Igitur qui desiderat pacem, praeparet bellum!"
Posts: 299
|
Post by Jash on Apr 17, 2023 6:58:13 GMT
Haha like my avatar of Shredder, I must live in the shadows like a good Foot Ninja. I'm pretty sure Sting also had the antiqued silver plated fittings, along with the silver vine work. Found this: "Handle Material: Solid metal guard and pommel, plated in genuine silver, weathered and distressed finish, hardwood hand grip, silver vine onlay.". And for the record, I do not consider MC Sam's sword to be part of the MC lineup haha. Not sure where they were going with that. Anduril was actually lined up to be the 3rd in the set, but I'm guessing that happened right near their bankruptcy... My thing is, UC also announced they're looking into making "Battle Worthy" forged carbon steel LOTR swords. Even showing a prototype of Herugrim on FB. So then my question is - if the only "MC thing" Anduril has going for it is the carbon blade, how will that differentiate it from this newer lineup? Unless the newer lineup will get a name change to "MC" themselves? I'm just debating semantics at this point. It's 2am and I can't sleep haha. Unlesssss "MC" will basically mean "the most accurate version UC makes". Then I think that will hold true for Glamdring, Sting, Sam's, and Anduril - correct? Don't get me wrong. Regardless of what I say, I'm probably still getting one. As I've wanted it ever since they announced Glamdring and Sting back in the day lol. And I will always support UC's attempts at improving upon their LOTR swords!  warriorpoet - thanks for the clarification! I recall the first run of Gimli's axes being "Forged Tool Steel" but couldn't recall what was used for the scimitar. And now: "Ninja Vanish!" [Tatsu] |
|
|
|
Post by curiomansion on Apr 18, 2023 23:19:06 GMT
Haha like my avatar of Shredder, I must live in the shadows like a good Foot Ninja. I'm pretty sure Sting also had the antiqued silver plated fittings, along with the silver vine work. Found this: "Handle Material: Solid metal guard and pommel, plated in genuine silver, weathered and distressed finish, hardwood hand grip, silver vine onlay.". And for the record, I do not consider MC Sam's sword to be part of the MC lineup haha. Not sure where they were going with that. Anduril was actually lined up to be the 3rd in the set, but I'm guessing that happened right near their bankruptcy... My thing is, UC also announced they're looking into making "Battle Worthy" forged carbon steel LOTR swords. Even showing a prototype of Herugrim on FB. So then my question is - if the only "MC thing" Anduril has going for it is the carbon blade, how will that differentiate it from this newer lineup? Unless the newer lineup will get a name change to "MC" themselves? I'm just debating semantics at this point. It's 2am and I can't sleep haha. Unlesssss "MC" will basically mean "the most accurate version UC makes". Then I think that will hold true for Glamdring, Sting, Sam's, and Anduril - correct? Don't get me wrong. Regardless of what I say, I'm probably still getting one. As I've wanted it ever since they announced Glamdring and Sting back in the day lol. And I will always support UC's attempts at improving upon their LOTR swords! warriorpoet - thanks for the clarification! I recall the first run of Gimli's axes being "Forged Tool Steel" but couldn't recall what was used for the scimitar. And now: "Ninja Vanish!" [Tatsu] I wish they'd just sell a license to Albion. One can dream right? I'd prefer a CNC'd blade blank to replicate Peter Lyon's beautiful hollow grind. |
|
|
|
Post by curiomansion on Apr 18, 2023 23:26:33 GMT
My thing is, UC also announced they're looking into making "Battle Worthy" forged carbon steel LOTR swords. Even showing a prototype of Herugrim on FB. So then my question is - if the only "MC thing" Anduril has going for it is the carbon blade, how will that differentiate it from this newer lineup? Unless the newer lineup will get a name change to "MC" themselves? I'm just debating semantics at this point. It's 2am and I can't sleep haha. Also where are these updates? I can't seem to find them on facebook. |
|
Jash
Member
"Igitur qui desiderat pacem, praeparet bellum!"
Posts: 299
|
Post by Jash on Apr 20, 2023 7:20:41 GMT
My thing is, UC also announced they're looking into making "Battle Worthy" forged carbon steel LOTR swords. Even showing a prototype of Herugrim on FB. So then my question is - if the only "MC thing" Anduril has going for it is the carbon blade, how will that differentiate it from this newer lineup? Unless the newer lineup will get a name change to "MC" themselves? I'm just debating semantics at this point. It's 2am and I can't sleep haha. Also where are these updates? I can't seem to find them on facebook. It's been a while... but I'm pretty sure it was in one of the LOTR Collector Groups. Posted by Drew Hall who works for UC. He usually teases with upcoming products, development updates, or prototypes. I can't recall if he said the Herugrim was a go or not, but they did have a prototype in for testing. Yeah, a LOTR / Albion team-up would be amazing. If Conan can have dual license, I don't see why LOTR couldn't do the same? |
|
|
|
Post by curiomansion on Apr 20, 2023 16:33:51 GMT
Yeah, a LOTR / Albion team-up would be amazing. If Conan can have dual license, I don't see why LOTR couldn't do the same? Exactly! Even if United came out with a $1200 (market) functional variant of their LotR swords, I doubt they'd loose many people to a $3300 Albion variant. Peter Lyon's blade geometry is so distinct. |
|
|
|
Post by Lionhardt on Apr 21, 2023 0:24:46 GMT
I keep mentioning to UC that if they made a fully functional accurate version of the Ranger, they would sell like crazy. It is a very simple design; UC has shown several times they are more than capable of making fully functional, high carbon, tempered, leather over wood, mild steel fittings swords! Why in the world would they hesitate to make at least the Ranger, and then go from there?! Now of course the hollow grind would take the complexity up if they decided to do it. But even that they can do. The Anduril that started this whole discussion is confirmed to have at least a slight hollow grind! So they can totally make a fully functional amazing Ranger. One concern was the cost. I, and I'm pretty sure plenty others, would pay big bucks for an official fully functional version. This new Anduril is going to be what, like $500? Surely they can produce a truly functional Ranger for less than $1,000 and I think have no problem selling them. Come on UC!
|
|
|
|
Post by Eric Bergeron on Apr 21, 2023 2:51:13 GMT
The ranger is my favorite of all the LOTR swords and I would happily pay for a fully functioning one, I came very close to purchasing the kingdom of arms version but it is 1 lb too heavy for my liking.
|
|
rschuch
Member
Sharp blades are good to have, if Shire-folk go walking, east, south, far away into dark and danger.
Posts: 868 
|
Post by rschuch on Apr 21, 2023 13:40:32 GMT
The ranger is my favorite of all the LOTR swords and I would happily pay for a fully functioning one, I came very close to purchasing the kingdom of arms version but it is 1 lb too heavy for my liking. Have you held one? To me for it's size it's a very agile sword. I don't do backyard cutting, but I've got a decent collection it's definitely one of the easiest to swing around and certainly works as a one handed as well. |
|
|
|
Post by curiomansion on Aug 10, 2023 6:49:42 GMT
Looks like the estimated arrival has been pushed back another year. Any updates on this?
|
|
|
|
Post by roth on Sept 6, 2023 3:06:30 GMT
Looks like the estimated arrival has been pushed back another year. Any updates on this? Good things come to those who wait. Sometimes. |
|
Jash
Member
"Igitur qui desiderat pacem, praeparet bellum!"
Posts: 299
|
Post by Jash on Feb 12, 2024 2:30:10 GMT
Well a kind of side subject, but related to the discussion - for those that don't know UC is now officially making a LOTR "Battle Forged" series. First up is Herugrim (Theoden's sword). Here's the description:
"This new Battle Forged edition of the popular Herugrim sword from The Lord of the Rings™ films is made in the traditional manner with a full tang, tempered 1070 high carbon steel blade (false edged), and lost wax cast hilt parts. The blade features a double fuller and a full tang that is peened through the pommel, just like the real-steel hero filming props. The hilt features a solid brass guard and pommel with fine detailing and an aged and worn finish. The genuine leather-wrapped grip is shaped from real wood. Herugrim comes with a black and gold wood wall display and a certificate of authenticity."
And although not confirmed... rumor has it that Isildur's sword is next.
|
|
|
|
Post by Lionhardt on Feb 18, 2024 15:22:10 GMT
Well a kind of side subject, but related to the discussion - for those that don't know UC is now officially making a LOTR "Battle Forged" series. First up is Herugrim (Theoden's sword). Here's the description: "This new Battle Forged edition of the popular Herugrim sword from The Lord of the Rings™ films is made in the traditional manner with a full tang, tempered 1070 high carbon steel blade (false edged), and lost wax cast hilt parts. The blade features a double fuller and a full tang that is peened through the pommel, just like the real-steel hero filming props. The hilt features a solid brass guard and pommel with fine detailing and an aged and worn finish. The genuine leather-wrapped grip is shaped from real wood. Herugrim comes with a black and gold wood wall display and a certificate of authenticity." And although not confirmed... rumor has it that Isildur's sword is next. I HAVE heard of the new line! Most exciting. Better believe I will get every single one they release. I would be VERY excited about an isildur sword. While I don't think I have heard that rumor, I do know they canceled the planned current rerelease of their normal Isildur. So that would make a lot of sense if that is because they are coming out with the Battle Forged version soon! Thanks for the info! |
|
|
|
Post by Lionhardt on May 28, 2024 22:11:39 GMT
Allegedly this is coming out any day now finally! We shall see!
|
|
haha 
Nov 1, 2024 0:13:58 GMT
Nov 1, 2024 0:13:58 GMT
