Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 16, 2011 5:57:40 GMT
So....I'm new to everything sword related....that including this site.
SO yeah...Hope you guys could possibly help me out. I've gone through a few posts and have come to the realization that I recently purchased one of these "440 SLO" that is a possible piece of trash....The only reason I bought it was because I got a set of 3 swords (I only saw the sheathe and thought they were un-bladed) for $25 dollars (US). SO I jumped at the fact that they were very nice decorative pieces.....and then realized they contained blades. Instantly intrigued...I've thusly begun my search for a decent blade.
So, later on today (assuming this forum is still active, forgot to check that) I'll attempt to take pictures and post them from my blackberry and post them on this thread so you all can laugh at my pathetic blade and yeah.....anyway. So yeah...I'm also looking for some recommendation for blades.....and if you noticed that I'm using the term "blades" a lot, its because I don't feel like making a fool of myself making up Japanese names for swords that don't exist. So yeah....I like the whole Japanese sword look. And yeah....Any pictures of decent ones would be nice as for anything else....so yeah.... Thanks.
|
|
Sébastien
Senior Forumite
Retired Moderator
Posts: 2,967
|
Post by Sébastien on Apr 16, 2011 6:02:14 GMT
Hello Darkdove, welcome to SBG ! Don't feel bad for your first swords man, all of us started somewhere and didn't know about everything the first day they shopped for a blade. Feel free to hang out here, and have fun doing so
|
|
Talon
Member
Senior Forumite
Posts: 2,554
|
Post by Talon on Apr 16, 2011 6:21:13 GMT
too true,i remember being in my local gunshop drooling over a sword (especially when i was told it was genuine 440 stainless steel) WOW a real stainless steel sword :lol: this site will teach you what to look for /and avoid welcome onboard darkdove
|
|
|
Post by caferacer on Apr 16, 2011 6:21:53 GMT
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 16, 2011 6:29:37 GMT
Hey Darkdove Quite honestly, if you're happy with them, $25 for a set of three display swords is a pretty good deal. I know you'll run into different opinions here, but we never want to be "sword snobs". Obviously you've got an interest in Japanese Katanas. If you can give us some kind of an idea of the price range you'd be comfortable starting out with, the guys on this forum can give you lots of really good recommendations as to functional swords. You may not know it, but this forum tries to focus on the sub-$300 sword market. There's even been plenty of discussion on this forum in the sub-$100 category.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 16, 2011 6:39:16 GMT
Yeah....didn't know I'd end up with so many replies already. Yeah....I'm probably looking around that under 100 dollar range. And yeah, I too was at a gun show....and found a set of katana's and some pocket knifes. My first gun show too. But hey, that Texas for ya. Here is a picture of what my set some what looks like. amkinindustries.com/blog/2010/04 ... katana-wt/ Anyway, the only true difference between that set and mine, is that mine has carving in the wood of the sheathe....and mine has no stand...So yeah...That's the best idea I can give you as to my current set. My blades....are....umm....Dull....in the greatest sense of the word.....as well as the previous owner that used it...Hell....I don't even know what he did to them but the first few times I un-sheathed the sword, the blade came out super oily (I read here that I just need to air out the blade), AND covered in grass or dried grass and dirt. So I need to find a way to clean the inside of the sheath out, but have no idea as to how to go about doing that. Thankfully its only the Katana (which doesn't make it that much better) but means that I only have to clean one....So yeah...Help please.
|
|
Talon
Member
Senior Forumite
Posts: 2,554
|
Post by Talon on Apr 16, 2011 6:59:57 GMT
web.archive.org/web/200411080145 ... ansaya.htm there you go looking at that article though i think cracking open the saya (sheath) is a bit excessive what i would use is either a thin barrel cleaning rod,or a wire coat hanger (straightened out of course) with a piece of cloth on the end,that should remove most of the dirt
|
|
|
Post by Adrian Jordan on Apr 16, 2011 7:38:57 GMT
Hello. I too am relatively new and exceedingly poor. For under $100, look into Musashi Swords brand. They can be found on any of the sites I list, and have swords from about $50 up. Their 1060 line is supposedly a great deal, starting at about $80. Also, the Munetoshi 1065 Beater, had at Swordnarmory.com( a great site,) for under $100. I'd look at Swordnarmory. com and the above mentioned Kult of Athena.com. Both have a large array of swords, and great prices to boot. Also, there is handmadesword.com. They have some katanas for about $100, but I have read some fairly negative reviews, and do not know how good of service they supply. This doesn't mean they are bad, I just am not sure. So welcome, and have fun.
|
|
|
Post by Wes on Apr 16, 2011 9:48:19 GMT
Welcome to the forum! Good on you for hunting out informed opinions before purchasing your next (and firsr real) sword! Budget is key, and if you're aiming at a production sword then it's a fairly simple thing to save $20 here and there until you have enough to buy it outright. If you want a sword to get out in your backyard with and do a little bottle cutting then $100 is not an unreasonable goal and we can suggest a few (mostly musashi) swords in that range. A better bet would be to set your goal a tad higher, aim for that $300 mark, and check Paul's reviews on sub $300 katana on our parent site. www.sword-buyers-guide.com/authe ... words.html a ton of good information there. Enjoy your stay, kick your feet up and stay a while
|
|
|
Post by deejay on Apr 16, 2011 12:58:51 GMT
Hi Darkdove-We all have had experiances from buying our 1st sword when we didnt know what we were doing-you can also check out Wiwingtswordsupply.com
|
|
|
Post by Elheru Aran on Apr 16, 2011 13:28:21 GMT
If you're interested in European blades, we can also recommend a number for you! The Tinker Series made by Hanwei are a pretty good value; for slightly more you can get the Valiant Armoury Angus Trim Practical swords as well.
For really cheap? The Cobra Steel swords made by Windlass Steelcrafts are around $55 each. They're kind of short and have a 'modern' look to them that some people might not dig; personally, I like them. Windlass also makes a number of other swords for under $100; try and check out the reviews on each item before you buy, though, as quality can vary.
Welcome, and enjoy yourself...
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 16, 2011 19:22:47 GMT
So yeah....I went to sleep (because it was 2 am here) woke up and finally took some pictures.....so yeah....feel free to point out things you notice about my blades....or just go "ew gross" to them if you must But yeah. None the less here they are. The reason I only have 2 of the 3 is because I gave my girlfriend the middle one (pretty much a short sword version of these two) because I wanted her to have part of the set and would have felt bad for giving her the smaller one, and would have regretted giving her the Katana (she'll probably only hang it up)....so yeah...No pictures for that one. Anyway, I showed my friend who is interested in getting a sword and who has done quite some research but doesn't truely know much and he had these comments. The wave on the blade (not sure the technical name) was faked on (I can see that being true) The blade would snap if I truely use it on anything because the nut at the end is actually holding a thinner part of the blade to the grip (its big at top but then thins and slides into the handle). The inside of the sheath is made out of plywood and that's the "grass" I keep getting on my blade....which means every time I put it in, I'll get ply wood out. And that it also has a poorly done plastic area at the front of the sheath so that I don't scrape as much as the ply wood as if it wasn't there (kind of a guide that can absorb the stab of sheath-ing at the wrong angle. And I noticed that the blade on the Katana's bladeis a bit wobbably in its attachment to the rest of the sword. So any comments about this would be helpful and you guys are great, I'm going to check those sites out as soon as I can.....Or as soon as I get some money.....Currently I'm sitting on $8....And I doubt I could get anything better then the ones I have now with that money.......Anyway. Thanks again.
|
|
|
Post by Adrian Jordan on Apr 16, 2011 19:26:16 GMT
Also, if your aiming to cut with your swords then you should shy away from stainless steel. It's great for knives, but can be dangerous if used with a sword. Try to look for carbon steel, between 1045 and 1095, or spring steel.
|
|
|
Post by Adrian Jordan on Apr 16, 2011 19:37:05 GMT
The wave on the blade is called a hamon(pronounced "ha-moan."). The hand guard is the tsuba(soo-buh,) the blade thins out to the tang, which is called the nakago. The handle is called the tsuka(ska.) The little brass or copper spacers on either side of the tsuba are the seppa. The brass collar at the base of the blade where it comes out of the tsuba is the habiki. You may already know these terms, but I thought they may be useful to you if you didn't, as there will be a lot of these terms thrown at you when you look for swords or ask advise. There are a lot more, but those are the most common. It would be a good idea for you to peruse the sword review section of this forum, which also has a link to the older reviews that contain reviews of many of the brands of swords mentioned to you.
|
|
|
Post by Maynar on Apr 16, 2011 21:43:25 GMT
|
|
Sam H
Member
Posts: 1,099
|
Post by Sam H on Apr 16, 2011 23:01:43 GMT
Welcome to the forum Darkdove.
First off let me say (as others have said) that I know all too well what its like to get started on this addiction. My first sword was also a stainless steel SLO. It wasn't till my sensei opened my eyes to real swords that I realized just what to look for in a sword.
Second I also want to say I know exactly what its like to be low on cash. At the moment I'm sitting on a total of $14 (in checking and what's in my pocket). Its rare that I have much more than $20 to spare at any moment in time lately... in fact having $20 to spare is already pretty rare in itself.
That all being said - if you can scrape together enough money (around $65) you can get yourself a functional blade with fairly low quality fittings but hey for that money the blade is all you really should be concerned about. At that price you can get a Musashi hand forged katana shipped to your home. While the ito (wrap around the hilt), same (ray skin), and sageo (cord around the scabbard) will be fake and probably look and feel pretty poor quality (compared to a more expensive functional sword) you'll probably find that it feels similar to what you'd find on your $25 set of SLOs. The biggest difference really will be the blade - it'll be made of 1045 high carbon steel rather than 440SS. This means that the blade will have a proper heat treatment and be usable in cutting practice without severe danger of the sword suffering a catastrophic failure. The sword will also be assembled at least somewhat correctly - as in full or 3/4 tang with pegs holding the hilt onto the tang. It'll be stronger than the rat tail tang of your $25 set and be more functional.
You can find these swords at any fine retailer that carries Musashi's line of katana. I personally would suggest Kult of Athena. Just click the banner at the bottom of this page and search for Musashi katana. They've built up a good reputation and a very solid return policy for their products.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 17, 2011 5:10:15 GMT
Well....I've been reading this www.sword-buyers-guide.com/cheap ... -sale.html and one thing I read that I didn't quite understand is the center of balance and the "tachi Kaze". The tachi Kaze interests me and I think that if I were to get a sword it would be a novelty I'd appreciate to have. And what i've read about the "Wind Dragon" in that page makes me rather interested in it. But I'd like to see if there was something for the same price that had a better "tachi Kaze".... And I appreciate the terminology, I know next to nothing apart from what I've seen and read here and other places in the past 24 hours. If anyone has a recommendation for something that fits a similar style to the "Wind Dragon" with a better "Tachi Kaze" and with a similar price (loving the $59) please let me know as it will most likely immediately perk my interest.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 17, 2011 5:20:21 GMT
I started my collection with similar stainless steel blade. I was enlightened to not swing them, though. It appears you were ignorant of that information until you came here, and that's ok. The important thing is that you know now,a nd have learned before injuring yourself. You mentioned you don't have a lot of cash at your disposal. If that is the case, I highly recommend you go to true swords.com, and purchase a musashi katana. Any of them. They are all amazing for their price, which is normally between $50 and $70. When buying swords to swing, you want carbon steel. Stainless just looks pretty.
other things you may want to pick up are some rags(or use old shirts alternatively) and some 3 in 1 oil to keep your sword from rusting. Welcome to the forums. I've learned a lot from these guys, and I think you will too.
Also, the middle sized of those 3 swords is called a wakizashi, and the one you called a dagger is a tanto.
|
|
|
Post by Maynar on Apr 17, 2011 15:20:48 GMT
The bo-hi (groove) is what makes tachikaze more pronounced. A sword without bo-hi can still produce it, just less audible. So any sword with a hi will easily give you the sound, used with proper cutting technique. The Bushido Wind Dragon is no longer in production, but a comparable sword would be the Musashi blade of the same name: www.kultofathena.com/product.asp ... gon+Katana However for the exact same price, you could have the Bamboo model instead: www.kultofathena.com/product.asp ... +Blue+Saya This sword features a true differentially hardened blade displaying a real hamon, as opposed to the wirebrushed hamon on the Wind Dragon's through-hardened blade. Generally considered to be more "bang for the buck." I own both the Wind Dragon and the Black Bamboo and I like both of them, albeit for different reasons. Any sword from this page should make a good choice: www.kultofathena.com/musashi.aspGood luck, and welcome to the forum.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 17, 2011 16:21:55 GMT
So the blue saya sword is better, despite having a slightly...umm...interestingly....blue saya? And is it just a concidence that the bamboo one is better? Or is it standard for Bamboo to be better? And on that note, what makes the bamboo one, bamboo?
Yeah, I don't plan on swinging my anytime soon.....except as a threat for possible intruders (in which case it'd still be a bluff and I'd be better off with my pocket knife). But yeah....as i realized first day (when i first got them), despite their ability to not kill a bottle....(who'd thought that's the first thing I came up with to try) they are rather decent at cutting (or beating) the board out of card board.....so yeah....anyway...If ever cardboard boxes attack, I'm your guy. Anyway. Yeah waiting on more information, the Blue bamboo sounds good right now, though I have no cash....but yeah...if anyone can think of better for same range price that would be interesting to hear about... Thanks.
|
|