Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 3, 2009 8:55:54 GMT
LPBoyle i followed the link that you sent me on yang family tai chi. the info found on site reads very much the same as Dr. Yang, Jwing-Ming's books. however the site is limited in articles for obvious reason of a man has to make his money selling the rest... what i was wondering is what is your source for the statement regarding the difference in teaching by Dr. Yang, Jwing-Ming and the ymaa, and the yang family? thank you. It was mentioned in, I believe (been a while since I read that) American Tai Chi living that Yang Zenduo divorced himself from the YMAA because that association would not follow his changes in form curriculum that he felt the need to make as lineage holder for the Yang family for the express purpose of divorcing the Yang family style from others that were being called Yang but were actually not. This included the Beijing Simplified style of the Wushu Academy, the CMC (ZMQ, Cheng) style that had been trying to distance itself from Yang to begin with, and the work of the YMAA. I have also heard the from several prominent Sifus such as Master Lee Scheele, Master William Phillips, Master Mario Napoli (the only westerner to win the Chen Village psuh hands competition), Master Show Hong of Taiwan, and some others. You may have noticed, I have done a lot of independent research about taijiquan. P.S. I was only one of several who recommended Jin-Shi although my own weapon from them is still in the design, and "where the hell am I going to get this kind of cash" phase. Which is to say Garrett's prices are very reasonable, I'm just very very broke.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 3, 2009 18:20:43 GMT
bloodwraith
i appreciate the understanding. while it appears that i have alot of knowledge, one can never have it all. that is why learning is a journey and not destination. thanks for posting tips, also.
LPBoyle
thanks for the expounding of knowledge. while i am far from being a master... i am teaching. to first teach, one must first learn.
also, which design of jin-shi did you order? Mine will be here tomorrow. it is only the production jian, as you said, "where the heck will i get the money phase" let me unable to get the custom yet. however if you saw my post on the United Black Ikazuchi, under chinese swords, which is a hybrid of katana/ jian, you can probably guess that i am interested in a tang jian. I hadnt thought of DifTemper for a jian, but it sounds good. would you think that it would affect the lateral flexibility, do you? My Ikazuchi is 1045 carbon, and monotemper, hrc 58. it is very stiff, but not rigid. it allows for a moderate flexibility so the chinese forms will still be effective. I am still working on my 32-form. not very polished at it yet. of course, if i ever become an expet, i guess i would still feel that i could learn more, after all it is a fluid art, capable of continuing change and growth. which style do you use. i would be most interested in exchanging ideas of improvement in my style. i use a hybrid mixture of katana styles mixed with 32-form and fencing. a little strange but offers a surprise element to those who use only one style.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 3, 2009 20:56:23 GMT
LPBoyle,
you have alot of knowledge of tai chi. so let me ask you a question about jian. historically speaking, what is the traditional preservative for a jian blade? i have tried silicon spray, which is not too bad, but the propellants smell very strong. so i prefer to use good old gun oil. however to admire a tradition of ages gone by, i would like to use the old method. what would you recommend?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 3, 2009 21:53:02 GMT
Need to think.
Okay, according to Chinese-Swords-Guides.com:
"Any fine mineral oil will do to protect a sword from rust. Sewing machine oil is a good standby if you don't have anything else. A specially made sword oil with an even finer grade such as the one you can get from Seven Stars Trading Co., is better. I wouldn't use gun protecting products on my sword. They smell awful for a start. Also, some products can deteriorate the wood of your hilt and scabbard. If you only want to prevent rust, any water resistant substance will do, but consider the scabbard. On the battle field in old times, it was probable that natural animal and vegetable oils were used."
I did a poll in the general discussion forum and the winners were 3 in 1 oil, and mineral oil. Unfortunately, none of my taiji resources get into the specifics of sword care as most of them tend to be concerned with the more philosophical aspects of the practice. It's taiji the philosophical is everything.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 3, 2009 23:09:53 GMT
also, which design of jin-shi did you order? .... Umm, Garrett helped me design my own, which he referred to as an Ox Tail - DaDao hybrid, to me it's more of an Ox Tail - Yang Saber hybrid (I mentioned I'm more of a Dao man, right?). I've just been going through some financial rough patches so it's taking me awhile to save anything. But when I can finally hold the melding of iron fittings, ebony, and sharp steel any wait will have been worth it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 4, 2009 4:43:24 GMT
LPBoyle
thanks for ifo on oil. the gun oil, from the info you just gave me, may be what caused my ikazuchi to slide in and out of the saya too easy. darn thing slipped out while i was holding it upside down (alcohol and sword dont mix) and cut my ankle.
you stated a type of ox tail dao. those are great. i love to look at them, just never took time to learn the style. you gotta do somepix when you get it. my jian should be here tomorrow or friday. i'll shoot some pix for you and send. the money issue hits us all. i guess thats why paul made this site for fans of swords that dont cut your wallet, just tatami.LOL. that is why i went for a production model.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 4, 2009 6:20:45 GMT
LPBoyle,
check this out and see if you can help... are you into japanese sword too. this could use alot of advise. /index.cgi?board=japaneseswords&action=display&thread=10552
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 4, 2009 8:51:17 GMT
Sorry, I don't do Japanese swords at all - if I started taking an interest in them I might lose my membership in the "Sick of Katanas" club. If it's a basic restoration MAAS metal polish has always worked well for me in the past, but that's limited to some antique agricultural stuff (sickles, corn knives, harvest knives) from back in my flea marketing days. The are others in the SBG forums far better at restoration projects than I am.
|
|