|
Post by Grav on Dec 11, 2023 16:06:33 GMT
Hello everyone!
I apologize in advance if the thread is clumsy, but it's my first time posting here. English is also not my first language, so it might be a little inconvenient to read.
To my understanding, S5 is not a frequently chosen steel for swordmaking. It was pretty hard to find any custom makers who even mentioned working on it. Seems to me that S5 is not suited for majority of blade designs, but the one in my mind is carefully thought through. The point is I would like to ask you, fellow sword enthusiasts, for help in finding people who know this steel well and will undertake to make a sword (or a bare blade) from it. I have a very perticular project in mind. It's a meaty blade but could still be considered a historically accurate project. Something like a very thick and short estoc.
Any piece of information would be an invaluable help. Thank you so much for any advice! Have a good one guys!
|
|
|
Post by blairbob on Dec 12, 2023 8:27:17 GMT
Cloudhammer as they have not only made katana/tachi pieces but euro designs
They are the only shop off the top of my head I know that has done Euro pieces in S5.
|
|
mrstabby
Member
Posts: 1,871
Member is Online
|
Post by mrstabby on Dec 12, 2023 10:55:43 GMT
I think Cloudhammer is probably the only one who does custom S5, I wasn't sure if they'd do a full custom euro, good to know. I have read they might also give you advice if they can offer different steel with better fit for you.
If it would not need to be S5 there would be more smiths available, but on an estoc I can see S5 doing better than most.
|
|
|
Post by blairbob on Dec 13, 2023 14:18:28 GMT
Yeah, I don't know if they would do a complete custom S5 nor have I heard of that besides that they had done some kind of knightly sword and a Viking blade and a tactical katana. So it sounds like they may have just been tinkering with the idea. not quite an estoc. i don't remember the proper name but basically beefier cloudhammerforge.com/products/italian-longsword-practical-sx105v not s5 either but possibly a bit cheaper.
|
|
mrstabby
Member
Posts: 1,871
Member is Online
|
Post by mrstabby on Dec 13, 2023 14:42:54 GMT
AFIAK Sx105v isn't as durable as S5, but it's up there with the best, more engineered towards edge retention than S5. I have seen the guy from RVA (can't recall the name right now) praising it for almost every use case over S5. But in an estoc I see exactly the case where toughness is more important than edge retention or wear resistance.
That's a very nice piece though.
|
|
|
Post by takitam on Dec 13, 2023 22:21:54 GMT
You need to ask yourself what is more important to you. A maker than can design and execute your project well (always a risky thing no matter what), or a maker that can use a specific steel type you chose for reasons only you know. It is unlikely that you can get both, so choose wisely
|
|
izzy
Member
14 Day Ban - Politics
Posts: 427
|
Post by izzy on Dec 14, 2023 5:34:24 GMT
AFIAK Sx105v isn't as durable as S5, but it's up there with the best, more engineered towards edge retention than S5. I have seen the guy from RVA (can't recall the name right now) praising it for almost every use case over S5. But in an estoc I see exactly the case where toughness is more important than edge retention or wear resistance. That's a very nice piece though. Exactly, one is a shock steel (s5) one is a tool steel ( sx105v), big difference.
|
|
|
Post by Murph 76 on Apr 27, 2024 22:07:11 GMT
S5 flats need too start materializing,the steel industry is missing out. Alot of people want knives made out of this shock steel.
|
|