|
Post by lmalterna on Apr 7, 2021 14:26:08 GMT
First post, so go easy on the old man.
Just starting my interest in swords and have spent hours watching reviews, reading threads. While I will start my practice with a stave then a beater, I want to plunk down a deposit for an Albion. Ultimately, I want a sword that I can be proud of, that would suit for real world use and I can pass down. Something built to last. Understanding that Albion's take time to come in, I want to put down a retainer on an order.
Style, blade length/style and weight---- I would choose a Norman blade, Count guard and hilt with a bronze scent stopper pommel. Obviously, this is not an option. The Reeve in H 1/2 would also appeal to me.
What I am left with is the Count, Crecy or Mercenary. Since I do not intend to fight anyone in plate armour, the thrust centric blade of the Mercenary is not appealing to me as cut is more important. Since I do not have a training bias, I can learn of whatever sword I choose. I would like to hear feedback from people who have used these swords on the good/bad/ugly or options that I am overlooking.
For now, I am starting with a Kingston Arming sword to get some feel for handling a sword but feel like hand and a half is going to be better for me than a one hand sword.
Thanks, Bill
|
|
|
Post by Lukas MG (chenessfan) on Apr 8, 2021 22:42:14 GMT
The Mercenary is the most nimble of the three, with the best point control and focused towards thrusting but can also cut. The Crecy is the best balanced between cut and thrust, the Count is optimised towards cutting. I personally have handled the Crecy and the Mercenary and would pick the Mercenary. The Crecy's grip is too short for my liking and the Mercenary is well suited to be used like a longsword (the most popular weapon in HEMA nowadays, with the most material to study). Longsword fencing is quite "thrusty" even against unarmored opponents so a XVa blade is a good choice. The Mercenary is compact and light enough to be used single-handed if necessary, I wouldn't say that of the Crecy.
I suggest if at all possible to get some training before picking a sword (type). You feel you'll prefer a longsword but you'll know with more certainty once you've had some practice. If you're sure about getting an Albion longsword in the long run, why get an arming sword first and not cheaper longsword? A H/T for example...
|
|
|
Post by lmalterna on Apr 13, 2021 22:08:29 GMT
Lukas, Thank you for your response. I spent some time looking over your web page- beautiful! Your XVIIIa Bastard looks Fantastic. I do wish my budget allowed something the likes of a custom. Being new to swords, there are a few styles I would like to handle. Just to move and do light cutting with. In one hand swords, I want to try a light arming, Messer, Viking/Norman(10th/11th century) and cutlass. So for trial and error, I will stick with good "bang for the buck" swords. A true longsword will be a bit much for me but the Bastards are where I am sure I will end up for any serious use/investment. I will not forget the Mercenary and it does get good reviews, one of their better sellers from what I read. For style, I love a nice fuller and I will not be fighting armor for thrusting, so the Stewart/Count have some style points with good function. More to think about while I make this decision. I do not live in an area allowing much hands on but if I can find a HEMA, maybe I can handle a model or two similar to what I am interested in.
Thanks, Bill
|
|