|
Post by toasterburn on Jun 15, 2016 23:33:49 GMT
I purchased these two today from a local thrift-store type place; the owner said he bought them from a soldier who brought them back from Afghanistan. It appears to be an antique Afghan Khyber sword and a Karud dagger, but that's as far as my knowledge goes. Is there anyway to date these? Does anyone have any idea of their value? Thanks!
|
|
|
Post by randomnobody on Jun 16, 2016 12:26:16 GMT
No real way to date them that I know of. These seem to run from 1800s to "recent" with many sources suggesting they're still being made and used by various tribal groups in and around Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, etc. I'm a bit confused by the scabbard on the sword, it looks very much of modern, possibly Indian make (think windlass, universal, that ilk) and the chain is something I haven't seen before. Going by the rust (which is pretty heavy, but I've seen as bad or worse) I'd say 100-150 years old or more? That scabbard is probably not original, it looks far too new, especially compared to the sword. Karud is right for the other, from what I've seen. Lines are a bit blurry at times between karud, pesh kabz, and choora, but the primary cited differences lie in blade shape and handle construction. By those yours should be a karud. Its scabbard is odd, but of a pattern I've seen before. Both are definitely Afghan, the karud a bit crude, but possibly legit. I've seen suggestions that sellers at bazaars and such sometimes have very poorly-made new blades made to look old for sale as antique, but I'm no good at identifying those. As for value, hard to say. They aren't particularly rare, or really very notable. They occupy a niche, but there's not a lot of real information on them like there is contemporary swords from elsewhere, so assessing value is tricky. I've seen some really nice ones sell for upwards of $700 US, I've seen one, at least, sitting on eBay for a year now at $300. That's for the bigger versions. I'd figure yours could fetch $2-300? Condition is decent on the sword itself, but that scabbard throws me off. As for the karud, it's in pretty rough shape and fairly small, even for the average. Maybe $100-150? I wouldn't pay that much, myself, but someone might. I'd probably be content to pay more for something in better shape... Here's an old with some info and chronicle of my own obsession with these blades: sbg-sword-forum.forums.net/thread/35151/khyber-knifeHere's a picture of my little collection thus far:
|
|
|
Post by toasterburn on Jun 16, 2016 13:21:55 GMT
Nice collection Random! And thanks for the info. I love historical weapons from different cultures, but this is my first experience with weapons from Afghanistan. I'm happy with those evaluations, I paid less than that for the pair.
I suppose I should add that there aren't any identifying marks that I can see on either of them. I was fairly certain the sheath on the Khyber wasn't original, but from what I've read the swords were used for generations with the sheaths often getting replaced whenever they wore out, so I wasn't too concerned. The sheath on the Karud is crudely handmade, leather over wood. It's old, but I would assume not the original. The handle of the Karud seems to be similar to the Khyber (brass and horn), but at some point it was wrapped in some sort of leather (maybe by the original owner, perhaps to make it more comfortable to use or less slippery?). In any case, the dagger seems solid; I wouldn't want to be attacked by someone with it.
|
|
|
Post by randomnobody on Jun 16, 2016 13:57:43 GMT
I wondered about what looked like a leather over-wrap...thing. I initially viewed the photos on my phone, which is not the best for impressions, and couldn't tell if it was wood, horn, or some kind of fabric or leather cover. I would still wager on it being a karud-style hilt, like this one: www.oriental-arms.com/photos.php?id=5416 (albeit probably not wootz, as this one is) but if you see brass, then it may well be a choora. I entered swords as a hobby with the Japanese stuff, like many, and had a brief interlude into European and then Chinese and Filipino stuffs, but nothing really stuck with me until that "Khyber Knife?" thread I linked previously sent me looking around for more info on the type, and now I'm in love with so many "middle-eastern"/"Indo-Persian"/whatever swords and knives, especially the Khybers and the Afghan pulwar. I want a lohar pick at some point, too... My smallest choora, the black-and-white horn grip on the bottom, has a 7.5" blade, which seems typical of the type. Above it is another with a 13" blade, one of the biggest I've seen around. I feel like I've seen a 15+" before, but can't remember where. Average seems to be 7-9", with a few up to 11", but almost never anything bigger that I have seen frequently. Your big one looks like it used to have a ribbed handle, like the biggest of my three, but it seems to have worn down? Somehow? It's odd, I can see patterns that suggest areas lower than the surroundings, but it looks smooth to me. Anyway, cool stuff.
|
|
|
Post by toasterburn on Jun 16, 2016 15:04:50 GMT
The handle is smooth; I think the ripples you're seeing are just natural patterns in the horn.
I got into the hobby when I took a year of fencing classes in college. Now I'm studying Kumdo (Korean version of Kendo). My collection is rather modest... a few modern swords and some antique fencing equipment mostly. Lately though I've started collecting a few odder things, like ww2 kukri's and bayonets, african masai swords, ect. Looking for a decent Khopesh and a Katar now.
|
|
|
Post by randomnobody on Jun 16, 2016 18:37:34 GMT
African stuff is pretty cool, too, and generally very affordable. Katar aren't hard to come by, but can get pricy. They're also pretty heavily mimicked, so there's a lot of newly-made junk that some might try to pass off as antique.
Are you familiar with Oriental Arms? They're probably the biggest vendor I know of for central Asian/middle eastern/Indo-Persian, African, and the occasional Filipino stuffs.
|
|
|
Post by toasterburn on Jun 16, 2016 18:58:00 GMT
No, but I'll check them out, thanks.
|
|