|
Post by LittleJP on Oct 19, 2010 3:23:03 GMT
I'm curious, have any of you wondered how a dismounted hussar of some sort would fight on foot? Would the sabre really be adequate to the task?
|
|
|
Post by Vincent Dolan on Oct 19, 2010 3:36:51 GMT
They'd be adequate and fully up to the task, all be it a little awkward as they usually required full arm swings to be fully effective. I can't really speak to European sabers, but what many people don't actually think about is that the Tachi, precursor to the katana, was actually a saber that was often one-handed or hand-and-a-half, especially in its early days. It was a very effective cavalry weapon, but somewhat awkward to use on foot, possibly due to the greater range of attacks that could be delivered on foot, whereas the curvature would be suited to a downwards or upwards slash, such as what would be delivered on horseback. While they're not the same weapon, I would imagine this would apply to European sabers given the similarities between the two.
|
|
|
Post by LittleJP on Oct 19, 2010 3:39:21 GMT
Ah, I've discovered that infantry sabres based on the 1796 pattern did exist, shame no company is producing them today. Only one handed use though, the only hand and half sabres I've found historically were essentially Grosse Messers and the like.
Looks like I'm ordering my first custom.
|
|
|
Post by Vincent Dolan on Oct 19, 2010 3:44:38 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Oct 19, 2010 3:48:29 GMT
Hello, Sabres on foot are very effective, if held and used correctly. Watch Cold Steel's "Fighting with the Sabre and Cutlass" DVD and you will see just how effective they can be. If you utilize effective and lively foot work and keep your sabre out in front of you in the the guard possition as taught in the dvd, it would be hard for anyone to get past your defense. And in the DVD it also teaches, besides your normal parries, guards, cuts, thrusts, etc, various grappling and disarming modes. I love the DVD and highly recommend it to anyone even remotely interested in fighting with a sabre. And you can use a one handed sabre in two handed modes also. Freebooter, Alabama
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Oct 19, 2010 3:54:47 GMT
Another thing, the curvature of a sabre is not just for better slashing and cutting, it is also to help in the extrication of the blade from a body after a good thrust. After skewering someone and you are moving on past them just hang onto the handle as you go by and the curved blade, using the back of it as a lever of sorts, just sort of naturally follows itself out and on past them. At least that is what I gathered from a demonstration I watched one time. FB
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Oct 19, 2010 4:05:19 GMT
Hey LittleJP, Here are two descriptions of fights with a sabre. They are from Robt. E. Howard's Conan story "Xuthal of the Dusk". While fantasy, REH did study boxing and some self defense and read immensly on such topics. So he knew a bit about it. And again, although a fantasy story, check it out. It is a pretty good description of sabre use against other weapons. And in the 2nd scene when he withdraws his sabre on the run from the guy's abdomine is a pretty good description of the curve of it helping in withdrawing and down more damage as it arcs through and out:
Two scenes from "Xuthal of the Dusk" in which Conan carries a sabre and his enemies short swords:1st scene: The supposedly dead man was rushing upon him, eyes blazing with indisputable life, his short sword gleaming in his hand. Conan cursed amazedly, but wasted no time in conjecture. He met the hurtling attacker with a slashing cut of his saber that sheared through flesh and bone. The fellow’s head thudded on the flags; the body staggered drunkenly, an arch of blood jetting from the severed jugular; then it fell heavily.
There Conan performed a counter-cut. Rather than dealing with his opponent’s attack defensively, the Cimmerian manages to meet “the hurtling attacker with a slashing cut of his saber that sheared through flesh and bone.”
Scene 2: A score of figures faced him, yellow men in purple tunics, with short swords in their hands. As he turned they surged in on him with hostile cries. He made no attempt to conciliate them. Maddened at the disappearance of his sweetheart, barbarian reverted to type.
A snarl of bloodthirsty gratification hummed in his bull-throat as he leaped, and the first attacker, his short sword overreached by the whistling saber, went down with his brains gushing from his split skull. Wheeling like a cat, Conan caught a descending wrist on his edge, and the hand gripping the short sword flew into the air scattering a shower of red drops. But Conan had not paused or hesitated. A pantherish twist and shift of his body avoided the blundering rush of two yellow swordsmen, and the blade of one, missing its objective, was sheathed in the breast of the other.
A yell of dismay went up at this mischance, and Conan allowed himself a short bark of laughter as he bounded aside from a whistling cut and slashed under the guard of yet another man of Xuthal. A long spurt of crimson followed his singing edge and the man crumpled screaming, his belly-muscles cut through.
The warriors of Xuthal howled like mad wolves. Unaccustomed to battle, they were ridiculously slow and clumsy compared to the tigerish barbarian whose motions were blurs of quickness possible only to steel thews knit to a perfect fighting-brain. They floundered and stumbled, hindered by their own numbers; they struck too quick or too soon, and cut only empty air. He was never motionless or in the same place an instant; springing, side-stepping, whirling, twisting, he offered a constantly shifting target for their swords, while his own curved blade sang death about their ears.
Conan, bleeding from a cut on the temple, cleared a space for an instant with a devastating sweep of his dripping saber, and cast a quick glance about for an avenue of escape. At that instant he saw the tapestry on one side of the walls drawn aside, disclosing a narrow stairway. On this stood a man in rich robes, vague-eyed and blinking, as if he had just awakened and had not yet shaken the dusts of slumber from his brain. Conan’s sight and action were simultaneous.
A tigerish leap carried him untouched through the hemming ring of swords, and he bounded toward the stair with the pack giving tongue behind him. Three men confronted him at the foot of the marble steps, and he struck them with a deafening crash of steel. There was a frenzied instant when the blades flamed like summer lightning; then the group fell apart and Conan sprang up the stair. The oncoming horde tripped over three writhing forms at its foot; one lay face-down in a sickening welter of blood and brains; another propped himself on his hands, blood spurting blackly from his severed throat and veins; the other howled like a dying dog as he clawed at the crimson stump that had been an arm.
As Conan rushed up the marble stair, the man above shook himself from his stupor and drew a sword that sparkled frostily in the radium light. He thrust downward as the barbarian surged upon him. But as the point sang downward toward his throat, Conan ducked deeply. The blade slit the skin of his back, and Conan straightened, driving his saber upward as a man might wield a butcher-knife, with all the power of his mighty shoulders…
So terrific was his headlong drive that the sinking of the saber to the hilt into the belly of his enemy did not check him. He caromed against the wretch’s body, knocking it sidewise. The impact sent Conan crashing against the wall; the other, the saber torn through his belly, fell headlong down the stair, ripped open to the spine from groin to broken breastbone. In a ghastly mess of streaming entrails the body tumbled against the men rushing up the stairs, bearing them back with it.
|
|
|
Post by LittleJP on Oct 19, 2010 15:22:48 GMT
I know those were used historically, but I was looking for something with more curve "cutting ability"
Does anyone know of any custom sword makers that would perform a job like this? Basically a smaller version of the Lt Cav sabre, usually used by infantry/grenadier officers and the like.
|
|
Luka
Senior Forumite
Posts: 2,848
|
Post by Luka on Oct 19, 2010 20:51:47 GMT
Sabers has no setbacks at all when used on foot. It doesn't give as much blunt trauma to the enemy, but nothing else. Curved blades are used on foot throughout history... Katana in street fights and duels was as effective as on battlefield when mounted, cutlass in the ship fights, falchions, messers... These are all curved blades used effectively on foot... Finally, there are a lot of infantry sabers from 18th century, they are just a bit shorter than cavalry sabers.
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Oct 26, 2010 6:51:20 GMT
Hello again, Watch this Youtube thing. It is a guy telling of a British veteran of Lebanon in the 1980s telling of how he and his platoon were set upon by three scimitar/Shamshir wielding Arabs and the tactics they used and how they held and fought with their "sabres". Very interesting and something to remember if in too close a quarters for full swings and thrusts, etc.. Go to: ... re=relatedFreebooter
|
|
|
Post by Ceebs on Nov 2, 2010 7:33:23 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Reflingar on Nov 2, 2010 17:11:10 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Nov 23, 2010 22:32:30 GMT
Man, that 1803 Infantry sword is a beautiful sword. I bet when it was all new and polished it was magnificant!!! Freebooter
|
|
|
Post by Reflingar on Nov 25, 2010 17:01:04 GMT
Indeed! I wish I could find one like that one day! And why, oh whyyyy the blade of the repro is so far away from the original??
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Nov 25, 2010 22:05:22 GMT
Reflinger, Hey Refinger, I too wonder why repros can not be actual correct repros, instead of something close?!? You'd think that with today's technology they could make a truly "exact" copy, a true repro! I have owned several original U.S. 1860 Lt. Cav sabres and I know what configuration the blades are, how they feel, etc.. I have owned repros from Ames Sword Co., MRL and another company (Ames and MRL's are identicle; blades made in India). All the blades are about alike and the distal taper is never right. Therefore the heft, balance, and feel is not the same. An original's blade is like a 1/4" at hilt and distally tapers to the point. These repros are 3/16" at the hilt and stays abt the same till a few inches from the point. An original is rounded on the back of blade, repros are flat (an 1840 Hvy Cav sabre is flat on its back though, but also just as thick at hilt).
So, why, with today's technology, can't any of these companies get it frigging right?!?!? Dang that pisses me off!
Over the last few years I have written Boker in Germany two or three times about their records from the 1860s, telling them about a buddy who has an 1860 Lt. Cav Sabre with "H. Boker, Solingen, Germany" on the blade that his ancestor used in the Confederate Cavalry. Boker has not even had the consideration, courtesy or class and decency to write me back with an answer. I told them with today's technology it would be so easy for them to make a "real" repro of their sabre from those days. I would pay good money for a correct made one made by them or Ames. But so far, Ames' blades are made in India and the handles and all at Ames and assembled there. Freebooter
|
|
Sean (Shadowhowler)
VIP Reviewer
Retired Moderator
No matter where you go, there you are.
Posts: 8,828
|
Post by Sean (Shadowhowler) on Nov 25, 2010 22:16:29 GMT
That 1803 Pattern British Infantry Sword is exactly what I have been looking for in a Saber... a damn shame I can't find anything like that.
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Nov 25, 2010 22:30:49 GMT
Hey Sean, Yep, it is beautiful. But I know where a sword is with almost an identical blade and shape, although the handle is different. Check out the attached pics of a Mamaluke sword from Legendary Arms (I think). I had one and it was so fine, so wonderfully made, and absolutely deadly (just a tad blade heavy for me). I gave it to a ladyfriend who loves swords). Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by Reflingar on Nov 26, 2010 1:41:58 GMT
Freebooter: I hear you, I mean, I can understand some shortcuts at a certain pricepoint, but when you can see the difference in blade curvature and length from a mile away... Sorry to hear Boker couldn't even get back to you with any kind of polite answer like "thank you for your interest but..blablabla" at the very least...(would have been even nicer if they'd accepted of course!!!) Just for fun, I've googled briefly for a 1803 pattern...and they sure don't give them away: An example, look at lot 2882, Auction 60, position 388-408: www.hermann-historica.com/?gclid=CKOZkoWkvaUCFY5d7Aod6gO8CQ(I love Hermann Historica: cool going throught their auctions for nice pics and close-ups!) Another place (without disclosed price), from a quick googling: www.swordsales.eu/1803-Pattern-British-Infantry-Officers.htmlHere is one to follow in case one might show up, a bunch of other interesting pieces also: www.britishmilitaryswords.co.uk/swords.cgi?search=1&searchtext=britswordEDITED to add: there is one for sale here (missed it the first time, then went back to check): www.britishmilitaryswords.co.uk/biggernewselect.cgi?search=1&searchtext=3026 375 British pounds! I remember you could find a good condition 1822 pattern officer's sword around the 400-500$ but the 1803 seems is way rarer, in demand, whatever: a lot more expensive... I had a few auction and antique dealers bookmarked that I used to follow their sales but, alas, lost them somewhere in an old computer.. (Did I post the link to this article already?: swordforum.com/articles/ams/1776-1815britishinfantry.php) p.s.: I'm pretty sure that Mameluke styled saber is from Weapon Edge, althought maybe sold at Legendary Arms
|
|
|
Post by Freebooter on Nov 26, 2010 3:20:14 GMT
Hey Reflinger, The one I am talking about is here: www.militaryheritage.com/mamelukesword.htm . Man is it a beauty too. I have owned one but ws conned out of it by a sweet talking Southern Belle of a huzzy (Got me nowhere too! LOL!)! I intend on getting me another one one day. Also, go to www.legendaryarms.com/uncavofpress.html . This is some sort of Union Officer's sabre, but what a beautiful sword. It is not the same as the 1803 but is very similar. I would like to have one, might just get one one of these days. I mis'well face it, if I was rich I would have a huge "study" or "library/war room/sports room" in my house and the walls would be lined with fine swords. No cheapies, no wall hangers just for looks and no modern military presentation swords with their cheap breakable blades. All mine would be real swords. Not necessarily antiques but fine "combat Ready" repros with fully tempered, hardened carbon steel blades. Oh well, let me hush or I would ramble on all night. Later, Freebooter
|
|
|
Post by MEversbergII on Nov 27, 2010 11:33:52 GMT
Let's also not forget the briquet; the French issued them to some of their foot units in the Napoleonic era. It was, from what I have gathered, not thought of very highly. Weapon Edge makes a replica, which you can get through Stromlo. I planned to do a review of it, but the economy accidentally my job before I could put up for one.
M.
|
|