|
Post by Iinenia on Dec 5, 2016 19:22:29 GMT
What about the Ronin Katana European model 7 ompared to the Hanwei Tinker Longsword? which is best? I am looking to get into getting my first sword and I have looked at many different kinds and different makers. Just want something that is tough and that will last. I like the ones from Valiant Arms and also the Bastard sword from Traditional Filipino Weapons, just kind of pricy for me.
|
|
|
Post by metotheeneni on Dec 5, 2016 21:39:54 GMT
Entry level: Absolutely the HT Bastard, or Longsword. Both are inexpensive - consider these to be "Volkswagon" swords. BLADES are excellent. SCABBARDS are functional, but less that optimum. The CONSTRUCTION of these blades lends to an excellent platform for customization. Short answer: GREAT sword, and you can screw with it as your budget allows. See the offerings from LG Martial Arts. See my scabbard tutorials. Seriously - on a budget? Buy one of these. You can turn it into most anything..... What about the Ronin Katana European model 7 compared to the Hanwei Tinker Longsword? which is best? I am looking to get into getting my first sword and I have looked at many different kinds and different makers. Just want something that is tough and that will last. I like the ones from Valiant Arms and also the Bastard sword from Traditional Filipino Weapons, just kind of pricey for me.
|
|
|
Post by Faldarin on Dec 6, 2016 0:23:42 GMT
Hey Iinenia(/metotheeneni?) - Even though I'm new, I can at least give an opinion here. I own a H/T Bastard, and the Ronin Euro #7, and I've handled the H/T Longsword. This is all my opinion, and I'm a newbie, so take it for what it's worth. In simple stats, the Ronin has a longer blade, and shorter grip. The H/T has a shorter blade, and an incredibly long grip. The grip alone seems to make the H/T a little easier to use, and makes it feel 'lighter' than the Ronin to my hand. (However, the Ronin's grip and pommel, as well as the peened construction, make it a lot more durable/comfortable of a grip.) They're both super-durable... the 5160 spring steel on the H/T speaks for itself, and I don't know what kind of heat treat the Ronin endured, but it almost feels like you could chop wood with it, without it even flinching (don't try it though, seriously). (Another note for the Ronin's durability, watch Matthew Jensen beating the tar out of it, if you want, seriously, he throws rocks heavier than a toddler at it: - Spoiler: The giant rock is what it takes to actually get the thing to take a permanent bend.) I'm sure the H/T could do almost as well in destructive testing, though, if not as well. Lastly, I'll bring it up... sharpness. If you want out of the box sharp, the Ronin is there. It's not super-sharp, but it's more than sharp enough to cut, and has no visible secondary bevel (very nice for looks, imo). The H/T longsword's edge... is pretty horrible by default. If you buy it from somewhere, use the sharpening service, or be prepared to do it yourself. I'm not sure I could recommend the H/T as a first sword without a sharpening service (unless you're REALLY used to sharpening knives or the like yourself). Again, all this with a grain of salt, I'm fairly new to this myself. These are just my opinions on these things! The H/T Bastard is an amazing 'lighter' choice, but still cuts fantastically (after a sharpening service, same caveat as the H/T Longsword). I can't say the Ronin is 'Better' than the Longsword or vice versa... but the Longsword is probably easier to handle... but if you plan on doing any backyard cutting... the Ronin would be the better choice if you want something already sharpened, hands down. Good luck on your decision, both are great choices!
|
|
|
Post by metotheeneni on Dec 6, 2016 16:12:52 GMT
Faldarin, hey man thanks for the input. I just watched that video and it seems to be a pretty tough sword. I have many other types of blades such as axes and tomahawks, and i just wanted to try something new. I have always wanted to get a sword for now for some years but just never got around to it, too scared I'm gonna buy something that isn't worth it.
|
|
|
Post by Faldarin on Dec 6, 2016 18:35:19 GMT
No problem. Both of those choices are very much worth it in my opinion. Availability on either can be spotty, price fluctuates a -lot- depending where you buy from. It should be around 250$ or less for either. General toughness is about equal... I'd say it should come down to looks, grip length preference, availability to buy from somewhere cheaper, and (maybe most importantly) if you're skilled enough to sharpen it yourself, or if you have a sharpening service available.
If sharpening is NOT an issue, these two are almost dead even imo, maybe with the 'performance' edge going to the H/T. The 'toughness' might go to the Ronin.
But then you're getting into COMPLETE OPINION. In a perfect world, you'd have both sitting in front of you to dry handle first, but otherwise... pick which one you like the look of.
*OPINION* If you're not comfortable with sharpening it yourself and don't have access to a sharpening service, I'd say go for the Ronin, from my experience If the above is true, but you don't intend to ever cut anything with it, go with either. *OPINION*
Ahem, sorry, I ramble on a bit when talking about something I actually have a little experience with. I hope you find one you enjoy!
|
|
|
Post by metotheeneni on Dec 6, 2016 22:01:21 GMT
Heck yeah I'm leaning more towards the RK 7, want something tough enough to battle orcs with lol
|
|
|
Post by metotheeneni on Dec 6, 2016 22:06:00 GMT
Have any of you seen this one?
|
|