|
Post by freq on Oct 3, 2022 5:06:23 GMT
www.zubladeworx.com.au/featured_item/shrapnel-dagger/ was reading a recent article about the new armaments the Australian armed forces are getting ad saw a thing about their new knife so i had a look, then went ewwww followed by great the army is staffed by mall ninjas lol, cannot see how this is a good design for cqc the ring would be perfect for breaking fingers inserted through it, has no guard and a bunch of speed holes in the handle for no reason,just cant see what they were thinking apart from oooh coool, would take a kbar or fairburn over this any-day all i can see is potential slips onto the blade, big giant ring that can snag stuff, not my cup of tea lol
|
|
|
Post by legacyofthesword on Oct 3, 2022 5:17:24 GMT
Haha, well I don't think it's particularly terrible. It certainly gives off mall ninja vibes at first glance, but I don't really see anything going on with the design that would make it less effective. I'm not a big fan of finger holes either, but they are used on karambits and the martial arts systems that use karambits are pretty well respected. Cutout holes in the handle would reduce weight, which is important for a soldier. No guard - again, agreed, I prefer something to stop the hand sliding down, but I suppose the idea here was to go with a minimalist approach, and it wouldn't make the knife significantly less functional.
|
|
|
Post by howler on Oct 3, 2022 5:44:04 GMT
Probably expensive for what you get. Looks like something mainly for getting someone off of you at grappling distance when they have pinned your rifle or handgun so you grab it off your chest rig and stab them with your off hand while backing up to get distance and re acquire firearms. Guess I'd need to know the weight & size and maybe go for the single edge tanto if large enough for utility tasks.
|
|
|
Post by randomnobody on Oct 3, 2022 6:51:40 GMT
Not that it's a terrible design but my immediately thought was kunai, which is not a good look for a legitimate, military knife...
|
|
|
Post by freq on Oct 3, 2022 6:52:15 GMT
Probably expensive for what you get. Looks like something mainly for getting someone off of you at grappling distance when they have pinned your rifle or handgun so you grab it off your chest rig and stab them with your off hand while backing up to get distance and re acquire firearms. Guess I'd need to know the weight & size and maybe go for the single edge tanto if large enough for utility tasks. couldnt find stats, but based on prices of other items in catalogue looks like it runs at 6 to 700 hundred dollars,
|
|
|
Post by freq on Oct 3, 2022 7:01:50 GMT
Haha, well I don't think it's particularly terrible. It certainly gives off mall ninja vibes at first glance, but I don't really see anything going on with the design that would make it less effective. I'm not a big fan of finger holes either, but they are used on karambits and the martial arts systems that use karambits are pretty well respected. Cutout holes in the handle would reduce weight, which is important for a soldier. No guard - again, agreed, I prefer something to stop the hand sliding down, but I suppose the idea here was to go with a minimalist approach, and it wouldn't make the knife significantly less functional. they do have karamibit , not military issue, have trained with some guys who were karmabit trained scary to see, scarier to try to defend against, but doubt most people who purchase this type of knife are going to have that style of training, got to say they certainly have a style they are sticking to, skeletonised or holes in any part they can
|
|
|
Post by freq on Oct 3, 2022 7:10:41 GMT
Not that it's a terrible design but my immediately thought was kunai, which is not a good look for a legitimate, military knife... yep thats where my mind went then here
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 3, 2022 20:10:08 GMT
The idea behind these designs is to have something quick draw, that you can keep a solid grip on, in case someone gets up close and makes it difficult to get to your gun. The idea is you can push them off with this, and still have your hand operational to use the gun. You draw it in an ice pick grip, for quick easy deployment, and this will allow you to get to your firearm much easier, in close quarters, such as hallways and what not
It's not something to be used knife against knife, in a duel, like you would see in hema sparring. It's not meant to be held out to "keep opponents at bay". This type of knife is better suited to grappling, like a karambit, or a lot of the shorter folding knives, or neck knives that have become popular for today's tactical based martial arts
|
|
|
Post by howler on Oct 3, 2022 21:14:50 GMT
The idea behind these designs is to have something quick draw, that you can keep a solid grip on, in case someone gets up close and makes it difficult to get to your gun. The idea is you can push them off with this, and still have your hand operational to use the gun. You draw it in an ice pick grip, for quick easy deployment, and this will allow you to get to your firearm much easier, in close quarters, such as hallways and what not It's not something to be used knife against knife, in a duel, like you would see in hema sparring. It's not meant to be held out to "keep opponents at bay". This type of knife is better suited to grappling, like a karambit, or a lot of the shorter folding knives, or neck knives that have become popular for today's tactical based martial arts Yes, this is my interpretation also, as stated above. A tool to regain enough distance to re-employ rifle/pistol, as quick deployment from chest rig to inflict offhand stabs and slashes to face, throat, etc...equal a lot of nasty sudden offense and defense. The Tactical Rifleman talks about this on YouTube video about best tactical knife, and his favorite is the Blackhawk Nightedge designed by Mr. Elishewitz, sadly no longer in production.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 3, 2022 21:43:27 GMT
Yea i would much rather have a push dagger as well. Would have all your fingers supporting it, and your fist, rather than it being locked to only one finger
|
|
|
Post by freq on Nov 27, 2022 8:37:05 GMT
found a pic of the guys holding this thing now even less impressed  only serves one purpose, stabbing, showed it to my dad (ex cadet armorer) his response was you cant use that for anything, its useless for survival, also found vid of the trash they appear to be teaching cadets www.facebook.com/watch/?v=531781973697303 this appears to be a defense against an aggressive cuddle, had ex student/ instructor from dojo enlist said he had cadets asking him to teach in free time because he was so much better, thought this was due to him being ex champion boxer/kickboxer but now not so sure, glad modern warfare isnt cqc anymore
|
|
|
Post by howler on Nov 27, 2022 22:14:56 GMT
found a pic of the guys holding this thing now even less impressed only serves one purpose, stabbing, showed it to my dad (ex cadet armorer) his response was you cant use that for anything, its useless for survival, also found vid of the trash they appear to be teaching cadets www.facebook.com/watch/?v=531781973697303 this appears to be a defense against an aggressive cuddle, had ex student/ instructor from dojo enlist said he had cadets asking him to teach in free time because he was so much better, thought this was due to him being ex champion boxer/kickboxer but now not so sure, glad modern warfare isnt cqc anymore Yeah, they seem to have removed the "utility" from combat/utility knife, with combat being specifically for re-acquirement of pistol/rifle with offhand when backing up from grappling. It is OK for that exact, specific function, but you give up so many other things. I would personally splurge on a few more ounces pain for increased ability.
|
|
|
Post by treeslicer on Nov 27, 2022 23:42:55 GMT
www.zubladeworx.com.au/featured_item/shrapnel-dagger/ was reading a recent article about the new armaments the Australian armed forces are getting ad saw a thing about their new knife so i had a look, then went ewwww followed by great the army is staffed by mall ninjas lol, cannot see how this is a good design for cqc the ring would be perfect for breaking fingers inserted through it, has no guard and a bunch of speed holes in the handle for no reason,just cant see what they were thinking apart from oooh coool, would take a kbar or fairburn over this any-day all i can see is potential slips onto the blade, big giant ring that can snag stuff, not my cup of tea lol
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 27, 2022 23:59:14 GMT
www.zubladeworx.com.au/featured_item/shrapnel-dagger/ was reading a recent article about the new armaments the Australian armed forces are getting ad saw a thing about their new knife so i had a look, then went ewwww followed by great the army is staffed by mall ninjas lol, cannot see how this is a good design for cqc the ring would be perfect for breaking fingers inserted through it, has no guard and a bunch of speed holes in the handle for no reason,just cant see what they were thinking apart from oooh coool, would take a kbar or fairburn over this any-day all i can see is potential slips onto the blade, big giant ring that can snag stuff, not my cup of tea lol (I'm kidding 😂)
|
|
|
Post by RufusScorpius on Nov 28, 2022 14:20:38 GMT
I am leery of any knife designed for the military that isn't either 1. a bayonet, or 2. a general purpose utility knife.
While this ADF knife doesn't seem too bad as far as tacticool designs go, it has a number of issues that make me question it's overall usefulness in a military environment. Any knife designed with the idea of "if he does this, then the knife does that, then this happens, then this happens, and that makes the knife useful" is bound to never be used in that specific situation. The lack of handguard is concerning, as is the very pointy tip that can be broken fairly easily. I also question the usefulness of the ring- yes it's great to tie stuff on and whatever, but it's not any better than a lanyard hole at the end of the day.
I would prefer the tried and true Kabar (or any of it's offshoots), Mk3 Navy, or Sheffield MOD. Any of those knives are good all arounders that will do anything you need- literally anything.
|
|
|
Post by treeslicer on Nov 28, 2022 17:21:58 GMT
I am leery of any knife designed for the military that isn't either 1. a bayonet, or 2. a general purpose utility knife.............. I would prefer the tried and true Kabar (or any of it's offshoots), Mk3 Navy, or Sheffield MOD. Any of those knives are good all arounders that will do anything you need- literally anything. Yup. That's a knife:

|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 28, 2022 17:38:59 GMT
I am leery of any knife designed for the military that isn't either 1. a bayonet, or 2. a general purpose utility knife. While this ADF knife doesn't seem too bad as far as tacticool designs go, it has a number of issues that make me question it's overall usefulness in a military environment. Any knife designed with the idea of "if he does this, then the knife does that, then this happens, then this happens, and that makes the knife useful" is bound to never be used in that specific situation. The lack of handguard is concerning, as is the very pointy tip that can be broken fairly easily. I also question the usefulness of the ring- yes it's great to tie stuff on and whatever, but it's not any better than a lanyard hole at the end of the day. I would prefer the tried and true Kabar (or any of it's offshoots), Mk3 Navy, or Sheffield MOD. Any of those knives are good all arounders that will do anything you need- literally anything. I think the ring takes the place of a hand guard, in that its used to keep your hand from slipping down on to the blade, by keeping a finger inside it (usually just the top half of the index finger, not usually the whole finger). I think the idea is that it's for grappling, as the general consensus is that a shorter knife works better for grappling. Easier to maneuver around, and less likely to be wrestled out of your hands
|
|
|
Post by RufusScorpius on Nov 28, 2022 20:33:32 GMT
So, you plan on taking the time to make sure you finger goes in the hole when you have an enemy soldier on top of you about to bash your face in with the butt of his rifle? And what will this do that a Kabar or MOD can't, or hasn't done already on battlefields all over the world? I say it again: I am dubious of the utility of any knife that requires an exact set of circumstances to happen in order for it to be effective.
In a military environment, simple and effective is better than engineered gimmicks.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 28, 2022 21:12:06 GMT
So, you plan on taking the time to make sure you finger goes in the hole when you have an enemy soldier on top of you about to bash your face in with the butt of his rifle? And what will this do that a Kabar or MOD can't, or hasn't done already on battlefields all over the world? I say it again: I am dubious of the utility of any knife that requires an exact set of circumstances to happen in order for it to be effective. In a military environment, simple and effective is better than engineered gimmicks. That's not the context it's designed in. For the last 20 years war hasn't been about professional soldiers fighting professional soldiers. Heck, this whole Ukraine situation is quite unique in that regard. When they were stationed in Iraq, it wasn't fully trained enemy soldiers they worried about. It was terrorist civilians. In occupied countries, typically, what you could potentially be facing is a civilian sneaking up to you with a knife, and trynna take your gun. People on this forum are so hung up on the most noble of weapon uses. A duel to protect your family from bandits, or against an enemy solider in a formal setting. But the reality, is especially lately, it's been more about random acts of violence. Even in the military world. You never know where your enemy is gonna come from, or how he's gonna attack you. Weren't you in the army? Were you stationed in the middle East? You are familiar with all this aren't you? Preferences are preferences though. I would rather have a messer, in how I imagine myself protecting myself against random attacks, or even using a blades weapon in the army. If I imagine myself and my opponent both conscious and forced to battle, sure, then even a gladius would be ideal for me over this little knife But if I was tackled by a couple guys trynna get my gun off me, I would want something firmly attached to me and instinctive to pull out, and maneuver around their arms and such, something difficult to wrench outta my hands. I wouldn't go with this design, but I'm assuming they are trained with them, and how to use them, so it's muscle memory. It is, after all, still the army I should specify, this isn't my own methodology, it's not something I came up with, and my word doesn't need to be seen as fact or even taken seriously. It's just what they think when they made this. It's how the world of self defense is too. There is new trends all over the place, and personally, I'm still attached to a lot of the old ways
|
|
|
Post by RufusScorpius on Nov 28, 2022 21:50:52 GMT
Weren't you in the army? Were you stationed in the middle East? You are familiar with all this aren't you? 1. Yes, 22 years 2. Yes , 6 combat tours: 2 in Iraq, 1 Afghanistan, 2 Kosovo/Bosnia, Panama 89 3. Yes. I know a lot of things I wish I didn't. One thing I can say for certain is that the Australian Army never consulted me about this knife design, so I guess my opinion doesn't really matter at the end of the day.
|
|